2D micro-focus fluoroscopy answers "is there a void, a cold joint, a misalignment here"; CT answers "what is the three-dimensional shape of this joint". The first is fast and cheap enough for line inspection; the second is slow and expensive but right for failure analysis and sampling. Most electronics factories run 2D on the line and keep one CT in the lab.
| Item | 2D micro-focus | CT |
|---|---|---|
| Output | A single projection | Three-dimensional volume, sliceable anywhere |
| Speed | Seconds | Minutes, depending on resolution and projections |
| Dimensional measurement | Possible with known geometry | Accurate internal measurement |
| Best for | Line inspection, quick judgement | Failure analysis, sampling, R&D |
| Cost | Lower | Substantially higher |
Focal spot size. Micro-focus means a spot in the micrometre range. Smaller spot allows higher magnification and sharper images, but reduces penetration.
Resolution. A quoted "1 µm" may mean pixel size or smallest resolvable feature — very different things. Ask which one is being quoted.
Geometric magnification. Set by the ratio of source-to-object and object-to-detector distances. More magnification means a smaller field of view; that is physics, not marketing.
CT scan time. Three to six seconds is fast scanning for in-line sampling; high-resolution CT commonly takes minutes.
Most lithium failures are internal: misaligned electrodes, folds, particle shedding, metallic contamination. In a 2D projection these are superimposed on other layers and hidden; only slice-by-slice imaging reveals them.
The usual pattern is sampling: take cells from each batch for CT to check alignment and contamination, while 2D performs full inspection on the line to catch obvious assembly defects.
Can a 2D system be upgraded to CT? It needs a rotation stage and reconstruction software; many systems support it, but confirm factory support before relying on it.
How long does CT take? From seconds in fast mode to minutes at high resolution. Resolution and time trade off directly.
How thick can micro-focus penetrate? The smaller the spot, the lower the penetration. A few to a dozen millimetres of aluminium is typical; steel or copper requires thinner sections or a higher-power reflection-target system.
Does CT need its own room? Yes. CT is sensitive to vibration, temperature and supply stability; placing it next to a production line usually costs image quality.
Radiation safety: dose, distance and shielding · Is dual view worth the extra cost
Product: 3C industrial X-ray NDT system
Want advice for your own site? Tell us what you inspect, the daily volume and the site conditions — we will propose an approach before proposing a product.